Any systematic
analysis of a composition. Term used in biblical scholarship in the basic
sense of the original Greek, techné
kritiké: "a technique of distinguishing."
Unlike literary,
art or music critics who evaluate the aesthetic merit of compositions,
biblical critics are primarily concerned to clarify the original form &
intention of biblical texts by studying features of the primary manuscripts
that are generally overlooked in religious exegesis. While exegetes try to
determine the meaning of the contents of a document, critics focus on
the characteristics of the documents themselves (material, script,
literary genre & style). Critics compare biblical documents with each
other & with similar literature from other sources, to identify the
distinctive traits & history of the biblical textual tradition.
The evidence
discovered by careful analysis of the textual data sometimes challenges
untested pious assumptions about the origin & character of the Bible,
producing controversy between conservative Christians (who defend traditional
interpretations of the texts) and those who accept new discoveries by
critics.
But not all
biblical criticism is innovative. The primary principle of biblical criticism
is that any theory about the Bible must be tested. To be adopted a
theory must explain the actual physical evidence of the biblical manuscripts
themselves better than other available theories. The theory that
accounts for most of the evidence is adopted as the prevailing working hypothesis
of the majority of biblical scholars. Scholars engaged in close examination of documents are not easily
persuaded to abandon workable hypotheses for unsubstantiated speculation.
Thus, biblical critics are more prone to exposing the flaws in novel theories
than to launching them.
While elements of
some aspects of NT
criticism are found in works by scholars of the patristic period (2nd-8th c.
CE) & Reformation (16th c. CE), the sustained investigation of the origins
of the NT text came to the fore during the Enlightenment a little more than
200 years ago. Since then several methods of analyzing the biblical text have
developed. Disciplines with a century or more of application to the Bible are:
The second half of
the 20th c. saw the burgeoning of new approaches to clarifying the
biblical text including:
These are
complementary rather than competing methods, with one often based on
developments in another. As in any modern scientific discipline, research in
biblical criticism is cumulative & collegial.
Other On-line Resources: